Coming from a third party reddit app, my front page did a good job populating itself with posts from less busy subreddits even though there were proportionally WAAAY more dead posts from /r/pics than from a smaller subreddit. Kbin seems to be showing waay more posts from RedditMigration and priacy right now because of how busy they are. Is this just because there isn’t enough content on kbin yet, or is kbin lacking a way of balancing what is showing on /subs?
It’s worth noting that Reddit itself has always been rather terrible at this. Some third-party clients fixed the problem, but on the website there’d be many subs that would never appear in my feed.
For the purposes of ordering a feed, a count of upvotes should be considered relative to either the total count of its magazine’s subscribers or the magazine’s average upvote count.
Edit: […] the magazine’s rolling average upvote count over the last n days.
I don’t know if you have expertise in the area but I’d be interested in different ways of ordering the feed (including the ones you listed):
There are probably dozen other ways to do this as well.
I don’t have expertise here. I do like your ideas, particularly upvotes relative to views. The strength of the upvotes:views ratio indicator should be a function of views, where upvotes:views increasingly matters as the view count grows. 0 upvotes of 1 view doesn’t mean much at all. (Note though that currently our view count seems to exclude other instances, as I have a recent post with more upvotes than views.)
Implicit in all of these is a time function whereby recentness is a main factor.