So I have heard people sometimes say the reason for no aliens is that complex life requires so many coincidences it is just incredibly unlikely to indecently arise anywhere else in the universe. I think it is a bit arrogant to assume all life has to mimic life found here on Earth, so forgetting the goldilocks zone for a minute, you still need life to emerge from nothing over the course of billions of years. Then you need complex life to emerge from that, and eventually civilization. But you know what else you need?

Extinction.

No extinction means no fossil fuels means no industrial revolution means no spacefaring. If it wasn’t for the dinosaurs, we would have nothing. Makes you wonder what we’re here for.

I conclude that any advanced alien lifeform that gets to this stage will have to use a source of power not used so much on Earth. Hydro and Thermal seem unlikely, it’s less portable and requires huge facilities, so it will probably have to something else. I imagine rivers of liquid gas, a space-faring civilization built upon lakes made up entirely of methane.

Edit:

It has been brought to my attention that fossil fuels are not in fact made up of ancient dead dinosaurs, and even if they were, we wouldn’t need a meteor to make this happen. I just like Dinos angry-hex

  • DefinitelyNotAPhone [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    8 months ago

    Man-made radio signals will degrade into unrecognizable, undetectable garbage within a lightyear or two just due to wave interference from all the other vastly more powerful radio emitters in the surrounding area. There is no Great Filter, it’s just that any intelligent life in our immediate neighborhood would have no way of making it clear they’re there (nor have any particular reason to want to, in all likelihood).

    The Great Filter is my least favorite sci-fi flavored shower thought, mostly because it refuses to die in much the same way that Roko’s Basilisk won’t either.