Hi. I am excited about waveform.social.
I already use have an account at mastodon.social, which is another ActivityPub application. In theory, Lemmy and Mastodon should be able to “see” each other. It should be possible to look up a Lemmy user or community from Mastodon, see the posts, and reply to them. This will be ugly in the interfaces but it is expected to work.
If I go to mastodon.social, and I type @mcc@waveform.social into the search box, it does not recognize @mcc@waveform.social as a Fediverse address.
This is not a problem I have with other Lemmy servers. Other Lemmy servers I can at minimum look up the users and see their profiles (sometimes I cannot see the posts without following first). This makes me believe it is not a problem with the Lemmy software. Also, the problem is not limited to mastodon.social. Users on other Mastodon servers see the same problem. So this makes me believe it is not a problem with mastodon.social’s moderation setup.
In a discussion on mastodon.social, we came to the conclusion this problem may be (1) on waveform.social’s end, and (2) due to your frontend caching/CDN/WAF setup. Of course edge caching is a good idea. But it appears you need to configure it a certain way to be compatible with Fediverse servers. As is, waveform.social might not even be fully compatible with other Lemmy servers.
Explanation thread: https://social.treehouse.systems/@megmac/110527459896730724
Thread related to waveform.social particularly: https://mastodon.social/@megmac@treehouse.systems/110527420111615988 (link goes to end)
The one sentence explanation is “The webfinger URL for a user needs to know how to accept the Accept: application/activity+json header.”
I do not fully understand all of these issues (my Mastodon development has been in mobile clients only) and I don’t know what your server-side setup looks like. If I am describing this wrong I apologize. All I know for sure is it does not work. If you can identify that the “no visibility” problem is happening at the side of Mastodon.social or the Mastodon software, I can go raise the issue at that end. I am good at pestering the Mastodon devs :)
Thanks!
Hey. I’m megmac over on treehouse.
I edited the post a bit since I did say http when I meant html in it, and the mastodon link-cleaning made hash of my curl command. It does appear to work correctly now using curl so I was probably doing something weird (I was trying a lot of different combos of different things to compare at the time).
Still, can’t seem to see anything from waveform.social from treehouse. So maybe it’s something else. Note, I’m not directly affiliated with treehouse in any way so I have no direct insight or anything. I do know there are other servers that have cdn stuff getting in the way (kbin.social was the main other one that I was looking at and is why I talked about cloudflare in that post).
As I was grepping the access logs I JUST saw something come in for @Megan. Was that you testing?
Possibly… I was also trying searching out from this server but I’m still pretty unfamiliar with Lemmy.
I did just try to search for “hithisismegantesting@waveform.social” from a different server I actually am admin on (sunny.garden) though if you want something easy to grep heh.
I think it’s safe to say that if you can find any reference to sunny.garden in your logs that’s probably me.
Haha yeah I was grepping on “Megan” and saw hithisismegantesting.
ah cool, so it is trying to find things on your server I guess, I wonder what it doesn’t like about it.
I just disabled the https redirect, does that fix anything?
doesn’t seem to have
In a little while I should be in a position to spelunk some logs from the other side and see if there’s anything explaining what it’s not seeing there.
ok so the thing is that rails isn’t just sending
Accept: application/activity+jsonand your server is returning html for pretty much anything that isn’t exactly that. I’m not sure what part of your stack would be doing that, but the bad behaviour can be seen by giving an accept header the way rails sends it which is:curl -H 'Accept: application/activity+json, application/ld+json; profile="https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams", text/html;q=0.1' https://waveform.social/u/megan(note: you can take text/html out of that altogether and it’ll still return html, just to avoid a red herring there)
You can also see that lemmy.ml does this correctly, if you replace the url above with
https://lemmy.ml/u/lemmyfor eg., so it seems that lemmy is capable of doing this correctly and it might be something at your webserver level (but I guess not your cdn if that’s still off?).Now that’s interesting… it’s the default nginx config that comes with lemmy that does this: https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/blob/main/docker/nginx.conf#L40
I will try and change that to be slightly more lenient.
Alright, do you want me to restore the https redirect before then or should I wait?
I don’t think http/https redirects are likely to be involved, so you should probably put that back (and the cdn too if you haven’t for the sake of your bank balance)
(oh context: sunny.garden also refuses to see anything on this server. Both can see lemmy<at>lemmy.ml if I search for that though so it’s not just “hates lemmy”)
I just removed my CDN to be sure, so wait for DNS to propagate and test again if you can. The correct ip should be 31.201.5.235. Let’s hope this isn’t going to make my bandwidth cry 😅
It’s about 4 hours later which unless you set a weird TTL should be enough time for DNS… I just tried @megan@waveform.social and @porphyry@waveform.social from the mastodon.social search. Neither went through. So whatever the problem is maybe it wasn’t the CDN. Honestly I would suggest turning your CDN back on that could get bad real quick if you don’t!! LOL
I am sorry to have set off a wild goose chase, I guess at this point what I’d recommend is escalating to either the Lemmy or Mastodon devs to ask if they know why it’s not working.
Alright, thanks for testing and troubleshooting with me. I will enable the CDN again.