sigh. Artistic works are often derivative. Even the music of Star Wars takes after Holst’s Planets, but it’s far from a copy.
The themes of the two go completely different directions. Star Wars is a fairly simple story of good and evil, while Dune dives deeper into politics and personality cults.
Hell, I’ll even defend Cameron’s Avatar from accusations of being derivative. You might find a list showing how it’s exactly like ten other works of fiction. So, why aren’t we citing those ten works as being derivative of each other? Yeah, the movie isn’t that good beyond spectacle, but even spectacle adds something that those previous works did not have.
to be fair, the main problem with avatar being a retelling of pocahontas isn’t the stealing aspect, but the fact they brought nothing to the table. It just felt stale.
Probably because when you see a Cameron make billions out of his name and advertising for a story he ripped off, it is hard to cast aside all the influence he used that didnt get the same money/recognition
sigh. Artistic works are often derivative. Even the music of Star Wars takes after Holst’s Planets, but it’s far from a copy.
The themes of the two go completely different directions. Star Wars is a fairly simple story of good and evil, while Dune dives deeper into politics and personality cults.
Hell, I’ll even defend Cameron’s Avatar from accusations of being derivative. You might find a list showing how it’s exactly like ten other works of fiction. So, why aren’t we citing those ten works as being derivative of each other? Yeah, the movie isn’t that good beyond spectacle, but even spectacle adds something that those previous works did not have.
to be fair, the main problem with avatar being a retelling of pocahontas isn’t the stealing aspect, but the fact they brought nothing to the table. It just felt stale.
Are you guys talking about Dances with Smurfs?
Probably because when you see a Cameron make billions out of his name and advertising for a story he ripped off, it is hard to cast aside all the influence he used that didnt get the same money/recognition