Yeah, I agree, and I don’t think I even disagreed with anything you’ve said here when this conversation started anyway, but even moreso now after reconsidering the source material more carefully. When I wrote this I was offering the reasons why people might come to hate her early on, based on my own feelings during my first re-read (“dammit Sansa why would you go to Cersei, of all people? AAAAAA you’re literally getting your father killed right now!”), and also then probably affording people too much benefit of the doubt for not recognizing her character’s growth as the series continues.
I still view early Sansa as a very flawed character (terms like entitled and self-centered spring to mind), but I think my own issues led me to hold her more accountable than was fair (see elsewhere in the thread).
Edit: Actually, I think I do have to point out one flaw here:
CW:SA
In the book series, at least, I don’t believe Sansa is ever raped; the girl who suffers at Bolton’s hands is actually Jeyne Poole.
She is not raped by Joffrey. She’s groomed by Petyr, and possibly assaulted by The Hound. She is also stripped naked in public which I would count as sexual assault.
Tyrion also leaves her alone, despite constant pressure from literally everyone around him to do otherwise. And then she’s just in a series of unrealized bethrothals.
Anyway, this doesn’t detract from your overall point: she suffers horribly for whatever relatively minor sins she’s really guilty of, and yet people hate her far more than is justified, and well past the point at which she’s genuinely not the same person she was at the start of the series.
Yeah, I agree, and I don’t think I even disagreed with anything you’ve said here when this conversation started anyway, but even moreso now after reconsidering the source material more carefully. When I wrote this I was offering the reasons why people might come to hate her early on, based on my own feelings during my first re-read (“dammit Sansa why would you go to Cersei, of all people? AAAAAA you’re literally getting your father killed right now!”), and also then probably affording people too much benefit of the doubt for not recognizing her character’s growth as the series continues.
I still view early Sansa as a very flawed character (terms like entitled and self-centered spring to mind), but I think my own issues led me to hold her more accountable than was fair (see elsewhere in the thread).
Edit: Actually, I think I do have to point out one flaw here:
CW:SA
In the book series, at least, I don’t believe Sansa is ever raped; the girl who suffers at Bolton’s hands is actually Jeyne Poole.
Also, please add a CW for the SA reference.
spoiler
She is not raped by Joffrey. She’s groomed by Petyr, and possibly assaulted by The Hound. She is also stripped naked in public which I would count as sexual assault.
.
Tyrion also leaves her alone, despite constant pressure from literally everyone around him to do otherwise. And then she’s just in a series of unrealized bethrothals.
Anyway, this doesn’t detract from your overall point: she suffers horribly for whatever relatively minor sins she’s really guilty of, and yet people hate her far more than is justified, and well past the point at which she’s genuinely not the same person she was at the start of the series.