I have between 20-30 TB of data I want to keep a copy of in a firesafe. I do not want to use an online storage solution, I want to maintain my personal data at my home.

My current plan is to get (2) Mediasonic HFR2-SU3S2 PRORAID enclosures and (8) WD Red Pro NAS 16TB drives to fill them. The first would contain a full backup and be placed in the safe. The second would be attached to my machine and receive nightly backups. Periodically, I would rotate the enclosures, taking the one from the safe and swap it with the one connected to my machine.

Are there any problems with my plan that I am not thinking of? Are there better solutions?

Is anyone else keeping a rotating data backup in a safe? How is it working out for you?

  • chkno
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    The benefit of using something fancier than rsync is that you get a point-in-time recovery capability.

    For example, if you switch the enclosures weekly, rsync gives you two recovery options: restore to yesterday’s state (from the enclosure not in the safe) and restore to a state from 2-7 days ago (from the one in the safe, depending on when it went into the safe).

    Daily incremental backups with a fancy tool like dar let you restore to any previous state. Instead of two options, you have hundreds of options, one for each day. This is useful when you mess up something in the archive (eg: accidentally delete or overwrite it) and don’t notice right away: It appeared, was ok for awhile, then it was bad/gone and that bad/gone state was backed up. It’s nice to be able to jump back in time to the brief it-was-ok state & pluck the content back out.

    If you have other protections against accidental overwrite (like you only back up git repos that already capture the full history, and you git fsck them regularly) — then the fancier tools don’t provide much benefit.

    I just assumed that you’d want this capability because many folks do and it’s fairly easy to get with modern tools, but if rsync is working for you, no need to change.

    • tonynOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      Thank you, it sounds great, I will look more into dar.