So i’ve been playing some old RPG’s, the First one was Final Fantasy 6 which i disliked, then i played Star Ocean, which i liked a lot, and now i’ve finished Breath of Fire.

First i must say that this game is old, and it feels old, very old. It feels like a game that is aware of being in a more powerful console than the 8 bits NES, yet it still doesn’t konw what a modern game is.

First problem, there’s no fast walk at all, you only have a slow walking speed. Over time you get used to it, but it’s frustrating noneteless.

The map, the world in general is quite massive in terms of space, with that walking speed it takes time to reach any place, eventually you get a spell that transports you to almost all towns, but that only makes the experience bearable.

Well heres the tip, the map is divided in large yet isolated areas, and each area has at most 5 places to go. Yep, the map is for the most part, quite empty but at first it gives an entirely different impression.

Another problem is NPCs and the events. The NPCs have this problem that, when a plot event is triggered they only say what they have to say once, just once, oh you forgot what it was? get fucked.

My last complaint is the interface, is quite chaotic, i don’t want to dive further into it, let’s just say that most of the options exist, you just need to explore it. The spells UI is the worst part of all, you get many spells but not an option that explains what they do, their names don’t help at all.

Many old games have these types of problems, the difference between them and Breath of Fire is that Breath of Fire is a very ambicious game, you feel the impact of these problems much more than with other games.

So after this session of complainig, the remaining question is, is this game worth at all?

My personal response would be. YES, totally.

First there is a GBA version that fixes the slow walking speed problem, unfortunately the music is worse considering that the GBA has worse hardware in that matter.

So let’s talk about the good points.

The combat system is AMAZING, it’s just entertaining and interesting to play, especially compared to Final Fantasy 6. There is much more strategy than FF6 althought the game is not that complex in terms of gameplay. The game is not easy, it has a moderate difficulty, it never resorts to overgrind in order to present a challenge, it’s a fair game with a fair challenge, and i like it that way.

The music is very good, unfortunately the last tracks are kinda generic, so it kinda falls short at the last quarter of the experience. Regardless of that, most of the overworld themes, the village theme, the shop theme and many others are nice as hell, it immerses you in the environment.

The story is very entertaining and i actually cared. It’s not nearly as good as FFVI but it has its own charm.

Graphically this game is excellent, despite not showing as many large elements as FFVI, many places share a similar structure althought the desing is different. The enemy desings and the characther desings are fantastic.

So to summarize. Graphics: 8.7

Battle System: 9.2

Story: 6.7

Music: 8.1

Gameplay/game design: 5.4

So this game is a solid 7.62, a good game indeed.

@xe8
link
85M

Solid review.

Have you played Chrono Trigger yet?

@lorabe
creator
link
45M

Not yet!

Before playing FFVI i had only played and finished Mario and luigi superstar saga and Pokemon Emerald (and the first gen remakes). The plan is to play most of the famous 16 bit JRPGs to finally play what i consider to be the two titans of that era.

Earthbound and Chrono Trigger.

As a begginer of this genre i can only judge the games based on how they feel now, not based on what they achieved back then. Having that said, i expect great things from these two games, they just look really good.

jonuno
link
5
edit-2
4M

deleted by creator

@bonedog
link
35M

I’m playing Chrono Trigger right now! I had gotten about 4 hours in, back when it was first released, and I’m not sure what interrupted me. I decided two weeks ago that I needed to revisit it and finish it. I’m 25 hours in, and will likely complete it this weekend.

@throwaway14
link
55M

Really like this kind of review

@someone
link
4
edit-2
5M

I tried playing Breah of Fire II a ago, however I was really turned off by the generic opening. I’ll play Ultima IV instead.

@lorabe
creator
link
25M

Oh, the Ultima games, they were the main inspiration for Dragon Quest, thus becoming the granfathers of modern RPGs, i’ll probably try them in the future.

@someone
link
15M

First two are kinda rough. I wouldn’t recommend playing them. However you also can’t skip too much since unlike Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest, Ultima has an overarching story. I couldn’t set up III very well so I won’t play it for the time being XD

@someone
link
15M

I think the proper story really start with Ultima IV tho.

bruhbeans
link
25M

Ultima VII via Exult is my mf’ing jam.

@someone
link
15M

Does Ultima VII have some improvements over original? The news page lists some known inaccuracies and issues.

@someone
link
15M

Yeah I really want to play Ultima VII, even if it all goes downhill from there :) But we have an overarching story so I’ll start with IV instead, once I find a pdf of “History of Britania” anyway.

bruhbeans
link
35M

I’d recommend the Lufia series, as well.

Bilb!
link
35M

I particularly love Lufia 2, bugs and all.

@lorabe
creator
link
15M

Definitely it’s on the list.

Bilb!
link
25M

I have tried to play this game several times over the last decade or so and I never get far. It has been too long since my last attempt to say more than I found it tedious. It’s interesting how the charms and the shortcomings of these old games just hit us differently.

@lorabe
creator
link
35M

I somehow think the charm and shortcomings of these games is what makes them so unique and memorable. Just for curiosity i played the third Breath of Fire game for the PS1 (just the fisrt half hour) and you can appreciate how much the franchise evolves while mantaining the essence.

Overall i think it’s worth giving the series a try, the GBA versions might be the friendliest ones.

How does your scoring system work?

Sub for everything gaming related!

Rules

  • Follow site-wide rules

TBD

  • 0 users online
  • 3 users / day
  • 25 users / week
  • 71 users / month
  • 170 users / 6 months
  • 1571 subscribers
  • 908 Posts
  • 1067 Comments
  • Modlog