In our recent paper on prompt injections, we derived new threats facing applications built on top of LLMs. In this post, I will take these abstract threat models and show how they will affect software being deployed to hundreds of millions of users- including nation-states and militaries. We will look at LLM applications in escalating order of stupidity, ending with attackers potentially compromising military LLMs to suggest kinetic options (a euphemism for bombing people with battlefield AIs compromised by bad actors)⊕ I guess it would be an evil use-case no matter if the battlefield AI was compromised by other evil actors- icing on the cake.

Let’s deploy LLMs everywhere! What could possibly go wrong?

  • 0xCBE@infosec.pubEnglish
    4·
    1 year ago

    This stuff is fascinating to think about.

    What if prompt injection is not really solvable? I still see jailbreaks for chatgpt4 from time to time.

    Let’s say we can’t validate and sanitize user input to the LLM, so that also the LLM output is considered untrusted.

    In that case security could only sit in front of the connected APIs the LLM is allowed to orchestrate. Would that even scale? How? It feels we will have to reduce the nondeterministic nature of LLM outputs to a deterministic set of allowed possible inputs to the APIs… which is a castration of the whole AI vision?

    I am also curious to understand what is the state of the art in protecting from prompt injection, do you have any pointers?

    • Capt. AIn@infosec.pubOPMEnglish
      2·
      1 year ago

      My take so far is that there isn’t really any great options to protect against prompt injections. Simon Wilson presents an idea here on his blog which could is a bit interesting. NVIDIA has open sourced a framework for this as well, but it’s not without problems. Otherwise I’ve mostly seen prompt injection firewall products but I wouldn’t trust them too much yet.

  • kiku123@feddit.deEnglish
    3·
    1 year ago

    This is a very interesting read given the hard press on AI that my company is pushing.

    I guess I’ll try to make sure that we don’t implement some of these really bad ideas.

    A lot of these seem to go away if you don’t connect to the Internet or allow user input, at least.