Best external hard drive

What is the best external hard drive in terms of privacy, security and storage capacity? Should I wait for a better one coming soon?

I’m looking for minimum 2tb of space (the more the merrier), don’t mind the cost

@OsrsNeedsF2P
link
102M

What do you mean by privacy/security? Unless you’re going bonkers, that’s down to the software you use with it

@Torquatus
creator
link
32M

Maybe “privacy” doesn’t fit the question, yeah I agree. Regarding security then, I see that almost any device comes with encryption by default, so I shouldn’t worry too much.

@peppermint
link
82M

There are some with hardware-level encryption, they might be licensed as military ones though. All others are somewhat bust. How about ZFS or LUKS for filesystem encryption and not worry about the specs too much?

@Torquatus
creator
link
22M

Very interesting, thanks for the suggestion! I hope it isn’t too hard to setup, I’m not tech savvy

@peppermint
link
3
edit-2
2M

I do it by following online guides, but not sure if there is an easier way. LUKS is like any filesystem you like on top of a logical volume on top of a volume group on top of cryptsetup container on top of a partition. ZFS is any filesystem you like inside a pool, and can support error correction and encryption. Someone else may know better about ZFS. For LUKS I found this except it doesn’t cover crypttab (automatic decryption when disk is inserted), and for zfs this is probably the standard point of reference. There’s also stuff like veracrypt but I don’t know how it works. LUKS is only for Linux I think, zfs might work for windows also - not sure.

@Torquatus
creator
link
21M

Ok nice research, although it seems to be as complicated as I thought… I’ll still follow the guide, thanks!

@ree
link
22M

Why zfs for a portable device? I’m not sure there is any advantage to that setup.

@peppermint
link
12M

I guess not, I just assumed a threat model where the main concern is that someone would remove a hard drive and read information off of it, rather than being able to conveniently use the data elsewhere.

@MedicareForSome
link
31M

Best buy sells these enterprise-grade WD easystore 14TB for $190 every black friday if you can wait a few months.

@eyeballkid
link
32M

I don’t think that brand matters much from a security standpoint, although I’d avoid any external drive with built-in wi-fi.

If you want a blend of privacy and convenience, one option may be to have more than one partition on your drive. On my portable SSD, I have one convenience/media partition that can be read by all of my devices: computers, tablets, windows computers. My financial/medical/business records are on a luks-encrypted second partition. I could probably have done something similar with bitlocker, but I’m much more likely to pull up my encrypted stuff on a linux machine.

@ThreeHopsAhead
link
32M

Don’t make yourself dependent on the hardware of data storage in the first place. Backup and if you intend to store anything sensible on it, just encrypt it from the beginning so you don’t have to worry about drive failures or erasing data. The drive itself does not matter much then.

@jollyrogue
link
22M

I usually buy whatever is cheapest. I have a mixture of Toshiba, WD, Seagate, and Orica enclosures plus misc NVMe SSDs.

Most of them get formatted and encrypted with LUKS. The Mac ones get formatted and encrypted via APFS.

@Echedenyan
link
22M

https://shop.westerndigital.com/products/external-drives/wd-elements-desktop-usb-3-0-hdd#WDBWLG0040HBK-NESN

Choose the size you want.

It can be found in physical stores too like Media Markt.

Ignore its OS compatibility, it is just a hard drive in a case.

@Helix@feddit.de
link
22M

You often can’t shuck the Element drives and they have proprietary controllers.

I’d go for a proper enclosure.

@Echedenyan
link
12M

Idk which was your case but yes, the physical controller is specific design, that is right. If you break it, unless you paid a secure there is no easy way to replace it.

You can always do what you proposed with a 3.5" hard drive from WD too which are very cheap.

@Helix@feddit.de
link
12M

You can always do what you proposed with a 3.5" hard drive from WD too which are very cheap.

yep, I’d recommend that. There’s also a list somewhere which shows you which drives can be shucked (=removed from their enclosure, without having proprietary connectors), but I can’t find it right now.

I’d never buy non-standard controller drives.

@artnow
link
3
edit-2
9d

deleted by creator

@Torquatus
creator
link
12M

Yeah it seems so, although I’m not convinced of the latest one with fingerprint recognition

A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.

Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.

In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.

Some Rules

  • Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn’t great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
  • Don’t promote proprietary software
  • Try to keep things on topic
  • If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
  • Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
  • Be nice :)

Related communities

much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)

  • 0 user online
  • 18 user / day
  • 77 user / week
  • 200 user / month
  • 599 user / 6 month
  • 3.6K subscriber
  • 1.95K Post
  • 8.81K Comment
  • Modlog