Any mention on fixing Eglstream for Wayland? It’s pretty much going to create a split in Linux ecosystem. :/

Ephera
64M

How are you going to fix that, unless people stop using the proprietary Nvidia drivers?

Every desktop environment would have to implement EGLStreams support in addition to GBM support, which is what everyone is using.

And as far as I’m aware, no desktop environment devs wanted to that yet – it was Nvidia, who contributed patches to Weston, GNOME and KDE.

So, that means two things:

  1. Nvidia is very unlikely to do that for smaller desktops, and those smaller desktops don’t have the resources to implement that themselves. So, for the foreseeable future, if you’re buying Nvidia, you’re locking yourself into KDE and GNOME (+ maybe some GNOME forks, like Budgie and Cinnamon).
  2. The core devs of GNOME and KDE aren’t too familiar with the EGLStreams-related code and if Nvidia doesn’t continue to maintain it, it’s going to take a long time for bugs to get fixed.
@BlackCentipede
3edit-24M

I don’t know how to go about fixing it, but if Nvidia see this as a signal that X11 is truly dead, then they’ll probably stop supporting X11/XOrg entirely (and shrug at us saying, “Hey don’t look at us, we are contributing to Weston for Wayland, it’s the fault of Gnome/KDE for not supporting EGLStream”) and then we’re left without any option… We can’t even use KDE Plasma/Gnome on Wayland using Nvidia Proprietary or Nouveau driver anyway on latest card.

So what are we supposed to do then? Idealistically, I’d drag Nvidia by the balls and force them to manually delete EGLStream and use GBM like everyone else, but that isn’t practical at this time.

@muesli
54M

How about not buying Nvidia cards and voting with your wallet?

Sure, but I still have to contend with using computer that I don’t own sometime.

@motorto
1edit-210d

deleted by creator

Ephera
34M

It depends on a lot of different factors, but you may be able to ride out your Nvidia card on X11, up until you would buy a new GPU anyways, and then buy an AMD card.
Like, X.org isn’t going to disappear by tomorrow, just because it’s unmaintained now. Many, or even most, games still target it primarily.

It will be interesting with laptops. Many high-end models only come with Nvidia chips and will likely continue to, because those problems are not as big on Windows.
But yeah, still, I would avoid betting on Nvidia for the foreseeable future, as much as possible. I don’t think there is a better solution.

Brian
14M

Not being terribly active with Fedora these days, I was surprised Adam was still actively working on Xorg (though I guess with Red Hat having to support RHEL I shouldn’t have been). I agree with him that killing off Xorg will definitely help Wayland down the road.

Maintainer: “I’m tired of maintaining this code because maintaining code isn’t considered sexy or glamorous, I’m going to put all my effort behind Wayland which is still a buggy, incomplete, problematic mess twelve years after its inception and just say Xorg is dead because I want attention.”

Shut it. Go maintain Xorg until you can do better. Wayland is not better. Let Wayland die. You’ve tried to force it down our throats for years now and no one is buying it.

All about open source! Feel free to ask questions, and share news, and interesting stuff!

Useful Links

Rules

  • Posts must be relevant to the open source ideology
  • No NSFW content
  • No hate speech, bigotry, etc

Related Communities

Community icon from opensource.org

  • 0 users online
  • 48 users / day
  • 91 users / week
  • 177 users / month
  • 291 users / 6 months
  • 2409 subscribers
  • 699 Posts
  • 1712 Comments
  • Programming/Software
  • Modlog