The problem with foundations (and many similar tribalism constructs) is that they are highly prone to politics and turf wars over non-issues…

@wraptile
banned
1210M

Foundations are founded for a purpose though — to do work nobody wants to do as well as to do PR for the movement/idea. This blog kinda compares apples to oranges.

@smart_jackal
creator
-6
edit-2
10M

None of the foundations are working towards their purpose. I don’t see FSF advocating vehemently for libre office or Linux Foundation asking people to install linux on their desktops. Only the community is doing the efforts, people are advocating open source themselves, not any foundation.

@wraptile
banned
1210M

But they do though. You’re aware that the whole GNU project including C compiler is under FSF, right? FSF is also funding free software education through free resources, public talks and so on.

Linux Foundation is not linux desktop foundation, their goal is attract corporations to use linux kernel. What you’re looking for here is Gnome and KDE foundations which are doing amazing work.

Foundations are about strength in numbers.

@adrianmalacoda
5
edit-2
10M

I don’t see FSF advocating vehemently for libre office

Actually the FSF does advocate for prominent free software apps, including LibreOffice. But the point of the FSF is to advocate for the free software movement in general, not specific projects. I agree, you should support specific projects by actually supporting those projects directly; that’s not the place of the FSF and one should not donate to FSF with the expectation that it’s going towards LibreOffice or some other project.

There’s more to the free software world than individual projects, and more to the free software world than developers.

(Edit: Not to mention, that open source and free software are distinct philosophies, and one of the things the FSF has to do is explain the difference. Of course, you are not helping “open source” by supporting the FSF because the FSF is not an open source advocacy organization)

@muesli
610M

If it were that easy. As a developer I’m happy these (and other) foundations exist, because they do the work I don’t want to do, couldn’t do - or simply wouldn’t want to waste my time on: taxes, legal advice, sending out donation receipts, handling of a non-profit legal status. All the overhead that comes with being able to legally accept donations in the first place.

Metawish
210M

My problem is that foundations are often 501’s, so I can submit my donation to be matched from my company. I think it just makes sense to do that and unfortunately, direct mutual aid and funding indie developers does not offer that same level of extra cash

@pavot
1
edit-2
12d

deleted by creator

All about open source! Feel free to ask questions, and share news, and interesting stuff!

Useful Links

Rules

  • Posts must be relevant to the open source ideology
  • No NSFW content
  • No hate speech, bigotry, etc

Related Communities

Community icon from opensource.org

  • 0 users online
  • 6 users / day
  • 45 users / week
  • 136 users / month
  • 486 users / 6 months
  • 3296 subscribers
  • 1048 Posts
  • 3055 Comments
  • Modlog